Not a MyNAP member yet? Register for a free account to start saving and receiving special member only perks. Across the past three decades, organizations have built up their anti—sexual harassment policies and reporting mechanisms—as required by law—and sexual harassment remains pervasive across many places of work see the discussion in Chapter 2.
This raises doubt about the effectiveness Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment these legally mandated mechanisms in eradicating sexual harassment. Even though laws have been in place to protect women from sexual harassment in
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment settings for more than 30 years, the prevalence of sexual harassment has changed little in that time.
This chapter describes the legal framework for addressing sexual harassment, the implementation of the legal requirements by academic institutions, suggestions for improving them based on research, and how federal funding agencies and professional societies have addressed sexual harassment.
We conclude that Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment legal system alone is not an adequate mechanism for reducing or eliminating sexual harassment. Adherence to legal requirements is necessary but not sufficient to drive the change needed to address sexual harassment. As such, academic institutions and federal agencies should treat the legal obligations for addressing sexual harassment under Title IX and Title VII law as a floor, not a ceiling, and work to move beyond basic legal compliance to promote sustainable, holistic, evidence-based policies and practices to address sexual harassment and promote a culture of civility and respect.
The development of law and policies Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment sexual harassment in academic settings began in the s, first with the passage of Title IX in part of the Education Amendments ofbanning discrimination on the basis of sex. Title IX applies to academic institutions receiving federal assistance, including financial aid for students such as student loansand bars the discrimination which includes harassment of those seeking education AAUP ; USED Title VII discrimination protections are based on employment status.
Women in academic science, engineering, and medicine fields may be students, employees, or both at once. The first legislative movement came under the direction of Representative Edith Green from Oregon, whose work on the Subcommittee on Higher Education produced evidence documenting Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment discrimination on the basis of sex in education House of Representatives, n. Title IX has become well known for its transformations of athletic opportunities for women and girls in educational settings, but its general principle is equal opportunity for men and women to seek and to complete their educations.
Though the details of institutional obligations have been
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment and may shift under presidential administrations, it has been a legal principle for decades that allowing harassment on the basis of sex to off access to educational Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment for youth or adults violates Title IX.
The concept of sexual harassment grew out of the second-wave feminist movement of the s, first coined as a term at Cornell University by Lin Farley and other scholars working on problems of women in the workplace Epp; for additional extensive history, see Baker ; Cahill ; Saguy Activist mobilization sexual harassment was energetic, composed of groups such as Working Women United, the Alliance Against Sexual Coercion, and campus organizing by students and faculty at Yale University and the University of Delaware Epp Popular media coverage of the issue in the mids included widely cited articles in the New York Times and RedbookMs.
The Sexual Harassment of Women on the Job. The Alliance Against Sexual Coercion, formed in Boston by anti-rape activists, published a detailed handbook in defining sexual harassment, outlining outreach and staff training for those working to combat it, describing how to survey to find out its extent within an organization, and outlining legal options for responding to Corcion Scholars and activists observed from the beginning that sexual harassment happened in educational settings.
To address that issue, the handbook includes a survey form designed for high school students experiencing harassment from teachers Sexual Harassment of Working Womenopens with several interview transcripts from women describing sexual harassment experience, including a doctoral student describing being sexually pursued and kissed by her male faculty advisor against her will.
Feminist scholars shaped both the legal doctrine of sexual harassment as well as administrative plans for changing organizational cultures to combat it. Feminist scholars also put forth detailed organizational policy recommendations. Backhouse and CohenCanadian feminists with careers in government and in business, published a management action plan in that recommended the core elements of organizational response widely used today, such as a strong policy statement from top leaders against sexual harassment; clear policy defining it and
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment that it is unacceptable in the workplace; posting and publication throughout company manuals and publications; trainings; oversight procedures, including surveying employees; protecting targets from retaliation; and a complaint and disciplinary procedure for addressing complaints— The original EEOC guidelines emphasized prevention of sexual harassment, and bythe EEOC cautioned that symbolic compliance with a policy would not be enough to shield employers from legal liability Edelman Despite this guidance, courts and the EEOC defer to the compliance structure that organizations developed i.
This report does not attempt to describe all features of Title VII and Title IX in detail, but instead draws out what scholars know about how these laws are working from
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment legal and social science perspectives and derives lessons for combating sexual harassment in science, engineering, and medicine. It is also important to
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment that this report discusses research on all three forms of sexual harassment and not limited by the legal definitions of prohibited conduct or what would likely be found illegal in courtbut Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment encompasses conduct which organizational policies could address in order to prevent sexual harassment from rising to the level of illegal behavior.
For example, one significant finding in this report is that the most common type of sexual harassment is gender harassment sexist hostility and crude remarks, i. All forms of sexually harassing Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment, 1 whether or not the conduct is sexual in nature e.
See Chapter 2 for further descriptions. Title IX addresses sex discrimination in educational programs or activities at institutions receiving federal assistance including financial aid, meaning that it applies to nearly all colleges and universities. Institutional compliance with both laws has taken the form of widespread adoption of policies and procedures to deal with sexual harassment complaints as a form of sex discrimination and to inform employees and students of these policies and procedures.
Unlike Title VII under which these policies are recommended and widely adopted but not required under the statuteTitle IX specifically requires the designation of an employee to coordinate compliance, adoption, and publication of a grievance procedure, and widespread notification that it does not discriminate 34 C.
The legal regime of sexual harassment therefore includes the major pieces of federal legislation Title Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment and Title IXbut also their judicial interpretations as developed through case law; regulations, guidelines, and letters from each administrative agency in charge of implementing the statutes; and the internal claims Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment and resolution processes in place within organizations.
While definitions of sexual harassment are similar under the two laws, Title IX and Title VII have different approaches to institutional liability for sexual harassment. Ellerth 2 and Faragher v. Employers are liable for a hostile work environment resulting from sexual harassment only if they were negligent, however—that is, if they knew or should have known about the harassment and failed to stop it.
EllerthU. City of Boca RatonU. Ellerth and Faragher cases provided a two-pronged affirmative defense for organizations accused Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment negligently allowing the hostile work environment variety of Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment harassment to go on: Organizations had already begun to adopt these personnel practices in the s and s, and by the time of these rulings inanti-harassment policies and grievance procedures were already widely used Dobbin ; Edelman Legal scholars and scholars of organizations have been very critical of the incentives and assumptions supported under the legal response to sexual harassment.
The incentive is to avoid liability by
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment policies and procedures, and the assumption is that targets Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment quickly and vigorously use them.
Lawton cites much of the same research relied upon here to show that it is actually quite unusual for harassed employees to report misconduct and to behave in the way courts seem to expect, especially when retaliation for reporting is common. Scholars of law and organizations have observed that in recent decades, large bureaucratic organizations such as colleges and universities are quasi governments unto themselves; that is, a college or university typically operates its own police or security force; runs internal grievance and dispute resolution procedures; dispenses punishments and sanctions; manages public relations and information services; and employs in-house counsel staffs as well as administrators to oversee this legal order.
The college or university is likely also the health care and psy. Since very few disputes end up in the courts Siegelman and Donohuethese academic legal orders will handle the vast majority of problems internally. Therefore, there are many legally significant features of these academic environments that extend Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment beyond sexual harassment but which have significant implications for addressing particularly for promoting transparency about how harassment claims are handled.
Transparency about outcomes may be Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment required, permitted, or prohibited depending on the type of conduct harassment that is also criminal versus noncriminal harassmentthe status of the parties students or employeesand the type of information an outcome of an adjudication, a complaint, a personnel document, or a police report Koebel For example, private academic institutions are able to shield their personnel decisions, adjudication outcomes, and financial matters from public scrutiny, but state public records laws variable, but modeled after the federal Freedom of Information Act apply to public state colleges and universities.
Additionally, the Higher Education Act of compels consumer-based disclosures by institutions that receive federal funds information about admissions, graduation rates, costs, financial aid, student services, Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment so on. The Jeanne Clery Disclosure of Campus Security Policy and Campus Crime Statistics Act known as the Clery Act also
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment to all institutions receiving federal funds and requires them to report crimes near or on campus, including sexual assaults.
So while the Clery Act requires all institutions to report a crime, state open records laws may require only public institutions to disclose
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment campus police incident reports, for example. The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act of protects the privacy of student records, including disciplinary actions, though after a finding against a perpetrator of a sex offense, the results of that proceeding may be disclosed USED Academic employers may also be sued for invasion of privacy tort claims if they release embarrassing information about someone, and colleagues may hesitate to warn about sexual harassment concerns in the hiring or promotion context out of fear of being Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment for defamation.
Confidentiality agreements in settlements will also shield harassment cases from view and make it possible for perpetrators seek new jobs and keep problems secret Cantalupo and Kidder The mandatory arbitration clauses that are standard in many employment contracts also bar women from taking sexual harassment claims to federal courts, handing them over to a quicker and less expensive arbitration system that shields the case from scrutiny and results in smaller awards Gough ; Colvin and Gough A study of employment discrimination cases found.
The use of such mandatory arbitration clauses in nonunion employment contracts has increased over the past 20 years since the Supreme Court affirmed their validity, Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment the extent of their reach into the academic workplace with its unique tenure system at least for tenured and tenure-track faculty is unclear.
The impact of binding arbitration clauses in the academy is not well studied, but any contract between an academic institution and its students or employees could currently require it. Adjunct and temporary faculty who are not unionized would be the most likely to work under contracts that remove access to federal courts through arbitration clauses.
Even if these claims were not barred by arbitration clauses from reaching federal courts, it is still the case that judicial interpretations of Title VII have been the primary reason that law is such a weak weapon against sexual harassment emphasizing existences of policies and trainings over their actual effectiveness when it is well documented that these are typically not effective.
Moreover, most forms of sexist hostility and derogation that research has found to be damaging to women in science, engineering, and medicine would not meet the high bar for illegal harassment. Greater ease of access to the federal courts for sexual harassment claimants would certainly benefit some women and could shift incentives toward prevention by Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment one liability risk management strategy, however. Thus, while academic institutions combat sexual harassment in science, engineering, and medicine, they must also attend to an array of competing and sometimes contradictory obligations that may hamper the transparency and effectiveness of their efforts.
Perhaps more importantly, institutions gain protection from liability by adopting standard practices that perpetuate ineffective policies and shield patterns, claims, perpetrators, and outcomes from scrutiny. The legal mechanisms in place to protect women from sexual harassment, and to address sexual harassment once it has occurred, have significant limitations. Any serious attempt to address sexual harassment through the law, through institutional Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment or procedures, or through cultural change should at a minimum take into account the social science research demonstrating that targets of sexual harassment are unlikely to report and that there are more promising practices to enforce policies on sexual harassment.
Perhaps the most distinct feature of the academy as a workplace is the tenure system. Union contracts or additional employment contracts add protections for workers above the at-will baseline. Tenure, by contrast, is a guarantee for a professor that after a period of probationary evaluation and review, she will be protected from being fired except for extraordinary reasons, such as financial exigency or program discontinuation AAUP Tenure protects the academic freedom of the professoriate, ensuring that researchers and teachers can promote knowledge and discovery without fear Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment those who dislike their conclusions.
Tenure does not necessarily protect professors who are found to be sexual harassers from Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment energy 5 examples of sexual harassment however, termination of a tenured faculty member is a long and difficult process. Cantalupo and Kidder assess 26 examples of lawsuits filed by professors with tenure who were terminated because of their sexual harassment of their graduate students, and find that institutions prevailed in 20 of the 26 cases.
Only 21 percent of
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment academic labor force is composed of tenured faculty, however AAUP Most are contingent faculty, including adjunct professors, who are hired to teach specific courses with contracts renewed term to termand graduate students and postdoctoral who also work as teachers.
In addition, medical students and residents provide care clinical settings, and undergraduates also work in labs and for professors on their research projects. The academic workplace and learning settings therefore extremely unequal based on employment security status: Tenured faculty members are hired and reviewed by the college or university under extensive faculty governance procedures, but other academic employees such as Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment assistants are likely to be hired by one faculty member on a project-driven basis and
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment be paid entirely through funds secured by that faculty mentor.
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment these inequities, people working, teaching, and learning together in science, engineering,
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment medicine will have very different perspectives about the safety of reporting sexual harassment and about other factors, such as investing time in a formal reporting process.
Any academic institution receives federal support must comply
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment Title IX. In practice, this means that almost all academic institutions must implement the requirements of this law, which has only relatively recently been visible as the primary way to respond to sexual assaults and sexual harassment on campus.
Colleges and universities have been under pressure to establish policies and procedures governing the Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment of and response to sexual harassment, but just as under Title VII, it is much more difficult to ensure that such policies and procedures are effective or user-friendly. Moreover, research has demonstrated that compliance with Title IX requirements is inconsistent, with many schools failing to meet even the low bar set by the legal requirements.
One study, which examined the websites of U. The researchers investigated four The study found that of the institutions that had a public policy, 70 percent were deficient in at least one of the aspects reviewed Fusilier and Penrod Brian Pappas, himself a former Title IX coordinator, has Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment two papers based on review of 1, documents and interviews with 14 ombuds and 13 Title IX coordinators from 22 large universities Pappas ab.
Another resource on the role and responsibilities of Title IX coordinators is available from the Association for Student Conduct Administration, a nationwide higher-education organization whose membership includes Title IX administrators. The association has published models for use in handling sexual misconduct cases involving students, drawing on a hearing model, an investigation model, or a hybrid of both Association for Title IX Administrators To address these concerns, several institutions have taken a close look at their policies and revised them with the intention of improving responsiveness and providing more options for recourse.
For instance, in the wake of a series of high-profile sexual harassment cases where those in leadership positions did not follow up on reports
Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment sexual harassment, the University of California system has now specified that all members of the Title IX team have clearly identified roles and responsibilities in managing all processes related to Electrical energy 5 examples of sexual harassment of sexual harassment.
In addition, a time line that ensures that all investigations are completed within 60 business days must be in place, and a decision or disciplinary action must be determined within 40 days after the end of the investigation.
Any recommended disciplinary action must be reviewed and approved by a chancellor or chancellor. After decisions have been made, all complainants and respondents will be informed of any outcomes.
MORE: Pansexual flag tattoo